Application of certainty factor in the analysis of the causes of commuter line and argo bromo anggrek accidents on trains at east bekasi station
Keywords:
Certainty Factor, Expert Systems, Incident, Incident Investigation, Level Crossing, Train AccidentAbstract
On April 27, 2026, a multiple accident occurred at East Bekasi Station involving a Green SM electric taxi, a Commuter Line train, and an Argo Bromo Anggrek train. This incident resulted in at least 16 deaths and 90 injuries. The complexity of the causes of this incident requires an expert system-based approach to systematically identify and quantify the causal factors. This study aims to apply the Certainty Factor (CF) method to analyze the causes of this multiple accident based on evidence collected from investigation reports, eyewitness testimonies, and technical operational data of PT Kereta Api Indonesia (KAI). Five main factors were identified: (1) vehicle technical condition – electrical short circuit in the Green SM taxi (CF=0.90); (2) human factors – lack of driver training (CF=0.85); (3) infrastructure – unofficial level crossing without barriers (CF=0.80); (4) train signal system disruption (CF=0.75); and (5) the limited braking distance of the Argo Bromo Anggrek train (CF=0.70). The combined CF calculation results show the highest confidence value of 0.9835 for the hypothesis of the main cause of the initial accident, and 0.9963 for the causal chain of the consecutive accidents. This study proves that the Certainty Factor method is effective as a tool to assist in investigating transportation accidents, especially in conditions of information uncertainty.
